I finally found the paper I needed, remember the 8.5x14 lavender paper I was looking so hard for! Well I found it at another office supply store in town. Here's how our wedding programs turned out:
I initially wasn't planning on doing programs, but had made tissue packets months ago and then I saw Mrs. Cupcake's accordian programs and fell in love! What do you think?! I'll soon post a DIY with the templates I used, so stay tuned!